Both brands make premium paints, and the better choice depends on the product line and the surface, not the logo. Comparing their published data for two flagship exteriors, Benjamin Moore Aura and Sherwin-Williams Duration, both are rated down to 35°F and both describe self-priming performance on many surfaces.
| Published detail | Benjamin Moore Aura exterior | Sherwin-Williams Duration Exterior |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum application temperature | 35°F | 35°F |
| Priming | Self-priming on most properly prepared substrates | Self-priming; one coat for repaints, two for unpainted surfaces |
| Darker colors on vinyl | Approved Colors for Vinyl palette; otherwise LRV 57 or higher | VinylSafe color palette |
| Spread rate | 350 to 450 sq ft per gallon | See product data sheet |
Sources: each manufacturer's published data sheet or product information. Sherwin-Williams also states a lifetime limited warranty for Duration, subject to label terms.
Usually not. Both manufacturers' instructions require clean, dry surfaces, removal of chalk and loose paint, and correct primers for problem surfaces. Benjamin Moore's Aura sheet lists specific primers for bleeding woods, masonry and metal. A premium paint over poor prep fails early regardless of brand.
Both brands make several interior lines at different price and performance levels. Benjamin Moore publishes data sheets for lines such as Regal Select (washable paint and primer, under 50 grams per liter VOC), Advance (waterborne alkyd trim and cabinet enamel) and Scuff-X (high-traffic). Compare specific products by their data sheets: spread rate, recoat time, VOC and recommended uses.
We use Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams products and choose the line by surface and conditions.
Look past the brand to the data sheet: recommended uses, minimum and maximum application temperatures, spread rate and film thickness, dry and recoat times, VOC content and the primer systems listed for your surfaces. For example, Benjamin Moore's current Aura exterior lists 350 to 450 square feet per gallon, a dry film of 1.4 to 1.8 mils, a 4 hour recoat and under 50 grams per liter VOC. Comparing those numbers product to product is more useful than comparing logos.
Joseph Assise III Painting is based in Easton and serves towns across eastern Pennsylvania and western New Jersey, centered on the Lehigh Valley. Town pages:
Allentown, PA | Bangor, PA | Bath, PA | Belvidere, NJ | Bethlehem, PA | Blairstown, NJ | Brodheadsville, PA | Califon, NJ | Catasauqua, PA | Center Valley, PA | Chester, NJ | Clinton, NJ | Columbia, NJ | Coopersburg, PA | Coplay, PA | Delaware Water Gap, PA | Doylestown, PA | East Stroudsburg, PA | Easton, PA | Emmaus, PA | Flemington, NJ | Forks Township, PA | Fountain Hill, PA | Frenchtown, NJ | Hackettstown, NJ | Hellertown, PA | High Bridge, NJ | Hope, NJ | Jim Thorpe, PA | Kutztown, PA | Lehighton, PA | Long Valley, NJ | Macungie, PA | Mendham, NJ | Milford, NJ | Mount Pocono, PA | Nazareth, PA | New Hope, PA | Northampton, PA | Oxford, NJ | Palmer Township, PA | Palmerton, PA | Pen Argyl, PA | Perkasie, PA | Phillipsburg, NJ | Portland, PA | Quakertown, PA | Riegelsville, PA | Roseto, PA | Sellersville, PA | Slatington, PA | Springtown, PA | Stockertown, PA | Stroudsburg, PA | Tatamy, PA | Topton, PA | Upper Black Eddy, PA | Upper Mount Bethel, PA | Walnutport, PA | Washington, NJ | Whitehall, PA | Williams Township, PA | Wind Gap, PA
Local guides with housing-age and climate data: Lafayette College, Easton | St. Luke's Easton Campus | Lehigh University, Bethlehem | SteelStacks, Bethlehem | Wind Creek, Bethlehem | Lehigh Valley Hospital, Cedar Crest | Dorney Park, South Whitehall.
Neither is better across the board; each has strong product lines. Comparing published data for two flagship exteriors, Benjamin Moore Aura and Sherwin-Williams Duration are both rated to 35°F and both describe self-priming performance. The right choice depends on the specific product, surface and conditions, and prep matters more than brand.
Both have premium exterior lines suited to the climate. Benjamin Moore's current Aura exterior and Sherwin-Williams Duration Exterior are each rated for application down to 35°F, which helps in shoulder seasons. Primers and masonry products in either brand may need 50°F, so check the full system.
Both offer vinyl-safe color programs. Benjamin Moore limits vinyl colors to its approved Colors for Vinyl palette or a Light Reflective Value of 57 or higher, and Sherwin-Williams offers VinylSafe colors in Duration Exterior. Choose from the brand's vinyl-safe list for the color you want.
Many painters use both and pick by product. A trim enamel, a high-traffic wall paint, a masonry coating and a deck stain may each come from a different line. Asking which specific products will be used, and seeing them named in the written contract, is more useful than the brand alone.
Sources: Benjamin Moore Aura Waterborne Exterior Soft Gloss (N632) technical data sheet; Sherwin-Williams Duration Exterior product page and customer information sheet; Benjamin Moore Regal Select Interior Eggshell (N549) technical data sheet; Benjamin Moore Advance Waterborne Interior Alkyd Semi-Gloss (793) technical data sheet; Benjamin Moore Scuff-X Interior Satin (N486) technical data sheet. Figures checked October 2026.
Licensed PA126039. $1M insured. Free written estimates after an on-site visit.
Book Free Estimate Call (610) 252-1815